45(1)

Guest editors: Rolf Biehler, Viviane Durand-Guerrier, Nicolas Grenier-Boley, Cécile Ouvrier-Buffet This volume gathers three invited papers in the frame of the international online seminar From University Mathematics to Mathematics Education (FUMME) held from September 2021 to December 2022 (https://hal.science/FUMME/). Klein’s second discontinuity is specifically addressed in these papers presented by Nicholas Wasserman, Nicolas Grenier-Boley, Carl Winsløw, and Rongrong Huo.


1. Adding diversity to mathematical connections to counter Klein’s second discontinuity

Wasserman, Nicholas.
For instructors that try to make university mathematics courses relevant to future secondary school teachers, doing so generally involves making connections between university mathematics content and school mathematics content–in attempts to counter what Felix Klein referred to as a “double discontinuity.” In this paper, I consider the nature of the mathematical connections that bridge these two domains, and common distinctions made in extant literature between them, such as directionality. Through this analysis, I point out another aspect of these connections that has been left implicit: university mathematics is primarily–and reasonably–framed as a superset of school mathematics content. In this paper I consider alternatives, in particular conceptualizing connections that invert this typical relational connection–i.e., a subset relational connection–and I exemplify these connections with concepts from university courses such as real analysis and abstract algebra. Then, I consider the rationale for doing so in terms of secondary teacher education, and the ways that diversifying our framework of connections in this way can be used to help counter Klein’s second discontinuity.
Section: From University Mathematics to Mathematics Education

2. How to choose relevant mathematical contents to understand and overcome Klein’s second discontinuity with future teachers? The case of the scalar product

Grenier-Boley, Nicolas.
The issues related to Klein’s second discontinuity necessarily lead to the question of the choice of mathematical contents on which to focus and the way to consider the teaching of these contents in secondary education. In this article, we propose to explore this issue in the context of the French educational system for the case of the scalar product. We use examples that seem to us to highlight some important issues related to this second discontinuity, whether for researchers, future teachers or students.
Section: From University Mathematics to Mathematics Education

3. From global to local aspects of Klein’s second discontinuity

Winsløw, Carl ; Huo, Rongrong.
The global question of how to identify, develop and assess mathematical knowledge that is relevant to future secondary school teachers, has been central in the emergence of mathematics education research from early on. We review parts of this history from the viewpoint of the anthropological theory of the didactic, and in particular the notion of relationships to mathematical praxeologies that are held by certain positions within school and university institutions. We also consider a modern case, where the questions arise in a very practical sense: how to bridge the gap between standard undergraduate mathematics courses and a school relevant model of real numbers and functions? We show how both theoretical and practical aspects of this more local question arise in a so-called capstone course for students with about two years of undergraduate mathematics experience.
Section: From University Mathematics to Mathematics Education